Skip to Content

The Case of the Sulky Girl

The Case of the Sulky Girl cover image Cover Artist: Roswell Keller
By: Gardner, Erle Stanley
Publisher: Pocket Books, Inc. (90)
Place of Publication:New York, NY
Catalog #: Kelley Coll. PS3513 .A6322 C2885 1950
Contributor: D. Harlan

General

Era: 1930s
Author as on Cover: Erle Stanley Gardner
Publication:1950
Original Date: 1933
Setting: urban; Mason lives in a "bachelor apartment," but spends one night in a "downtown hotel." The house where the murder takes place is a mansion located down a winding driveway from a hill in a "scenic subdivision."

Plot Summary

Fran Celane approaches Perry Mason about the trust (over one million dollars) left her by her father Carl Celane upon his death two years before. His will provides that if she should marry before she turns 25, the trustee has the option to give her $5000 from the trust fund and turn the balance over to charitable institutions. Fran, age 23, wants to get married now, and wants Mason to find a way for her to do so. As Mason learns, she has already been secretly married, and hours after Mason meets with the trustee, Fran's uncle Edward Norton, Norton is murdered. Norton's chauffeur, Pete Devoe, is the first suspect, but he is released when the heavy stick with which Norton was killed is found to belong to Rob Gleason, Fran's fiancé/husband. Both are arrested for murder and are tried together, with Mason representing both. Mason uncovers the real killer at the trial.

Major Characters

Perry Mason "Chief," adult male, old enough to have had "thousands of clients," gives the impression of bigness; not the bigness of fat, but the bigness of strength -- broad shoulders, rugged face, steady patient eyes, heavy eyebrows, trial lawyer, preferably before juries ("I don't go in much for wills"), has the reputation of being able to "stampede" every case he tries

Arthur Crinston adult male, 45 years old, broad-shoulders, affable, booming voice, feels kindly and protective toward Fran Celane; partner of Edward Norton in buying, selling and mortgaging real estate and buying and selling stocks and bonds

Edward Norton adult male, 55 years old, tall, bland, expressionless countenance, bony forefinger, partner of Arthur Crinston in buying, selling, and mortgaging real estate and buying and selling stocks and bonds; trustee of trust fund left to Fran Celane; her uncle and guardian as well

Della Street adult female, "about 27 years old," her manner radiates assurance and efficiency, Mason's combination stenographer and secretary, with whom he discusses the case

Paul Drake adult male, tall, long neck, protruding glassy eyes, perpetual expression of droll humor; sits sideways in chair in Mason's office, legs crossed over the arm of the chair; owner of the Drake Detective Agency

Frances Celane "Fran," adult female, 23 years old, "judged by any standard, she was beautiful," silken hair which gives a spun-gold effect, large dark eyes, high cheekbones, full well-formed lips, small yet perfectly proportioned; heiress, niece of Edward Norton, secretly married to Rob Gleason

Rob Gleason adult male, late 20s or early 30s, thin, very pointed nose, large ears, walks with nervous, jerky steps; secretly married to Fran Celane

Frank Everly adult male, in his 20s, just out of law school, unruly hair, pathetically eager face, young lawyer getting practical experience in Mason's office

Don Graves adult male, slender, well-dressed, yellow hair, brown eyes, a certain alertness about him; Edward Norton's secretary

Edna Mayfield adult female, short, broad, heavily-muscled, big-boned, capable, self-reliant, rugged features, rounded heavy chin, nose distended at the nostrils, high forehead, black snapping eyes; housekeeper

Weapons

heavy walking stick

Level of Violence

Edward Norton's murder occurs offstage. Mason twists George Blackman's hand down and around by grasping Blackman's extended forefinger and shoves him out of his office.

Sexuality

very small role in the plot; Fran Celane wants to get married now, at age 23, not when she turns 25. A newspaper reported directs his photographer to have Fran "show a little leg" to play up the sex angle in the case.

Ethnicity

race and ethnicity are not mentioned; "white" is assumed because no restrictions have been placed on anyone in terms of social mobility or housing.

Alcohol/Drug Abuse

Pete Devoe, Edward Norton's chauffeur, is found drunk and is the first suspect in the murder. Mason, Don Graves, and Paul Drake smoke cigarettes (Paul rolls his own). Harry Nevers, the reporter, drinks rye or whiskey whenever he appears.

Law Enforcement

local police (referred to as "the Central Police Station in this city") investigate the murder. Private detective Paul Drake does some legwork for Mason.

Added Features

the case generates big headlines in the newspapers: "NEW MYSTERY IN MILLIONAIRE MURDER....WOMAN IN ROOM AT TIME OF CRIME IS CLAIMED...." and three others on one page of one evening paper. Harry Nevers, the reporter with the Star, uses a good deal of period slang: "I doped out the play as soon as I got the call." "With the hardboiled bunch I'm working for, brother, if you don't know what you want, you'll never get it." "Get that jane to show a little leg." "That's oke." The Star photographer uses a flashgun which is filled with flashlight powder rather than electric bulbs, because of "the eagle-eyed bird that audits the expense account." About one-third of the book is devoted to a description of the trial.

Subject Headings

Trials/ California - Los Angeles/ Mason, Perry/ Murder/ Law and Lawyers/ Wealth